Monday, November 09, 2026
Maspalomas 24h | Newspaper of Maspalomas and Southern Gran Canaria
Alcor Seguridad condemns the unfair dismissal of a security guard at the Chira-Soria construction site, South of Gran Canaria

Alcor Seguridad condemns the unfair dismissal of a security guard at the Chira-Soria construction site, South of Gran Canaria

GARA HERNÁNDEZ - M24H Monday, October 26, 2026

 

The High Court of Justice of the Canary Islands has resolved a labor dispute stemming from the change in private security services at the Chira-Soria hydroelectric plant construction site in the Arguineguín ravine. The Social Chamber upheld the unfair dismissal of a security guard whom the outgoing contractor, Ilunion Seguridad, removed from its records, citing a mandatory staff transfer that the incoming contractor, Alcor Seguridad, refused to implement.

The dispute originated in June 2023. Red Eléctrica de España announced the termination of its contract with Ilunion Seguridad at the hydroelectric complex, transferring the access control to Alcor Seguridad for the construction sites. The outgoing company notified the workers of their formal termination, effective July 1st, and submitted the documentation for statutory transfer of employment in accordance with the Workers' Statute and the National Collective Bargaining Agreement for Security Companies. Alcor Seguridad assumed on-site operations the following day, deploying its personnel to the camp's esplanade and the tunnel entrance between Las Filipinas and El Caidero, but failed to register or assign the plaintiff.

The initial lawsuit filed in the Las Palmas courts sought to have the dismissal declared null and void, arguing that it constituted a disguised collective dismissal without the required procedures. The worker maintained that the lack of a proper transfer process affected 14 employees whose contracts were terminated simultaneously during the transition between contracts. The lower court rejected the claim of nullity, considering that the terminations registered with Social Security did not, in themselves, prove a fraudulent collective dismissal procedure as defined in the Workers' Statute. However, it did declare the dismissal unfair and ordered Alcor Seguridad to compensate the security guard with €1.150 or reinstate him with back pay.

In the appeal, the opinion drafted by Judge Gloria Poyatos Matas dismissed the plaintiff's claims for factual review, as the numerical threshold for collective dismissal was not proven. The court did, however, correct the lower court's ruling regarding the procedural standing of the outgoing company. The court clarified that Ilunion Seguridad retains its standing as a defendant because it was the entity that signed the original contract and initiated the termination by subrogation, even though the material responsibility for the dismissal lies with Alcor Seguridad.

The ruling upholds the acquittal of the remaining co-defendants in the proceedings, including the Wage Guarantee Fund (FOGASA), Red Eléctrica de España, the joint venture Central Hidroeléctrica Salto de Chira, and the construction companies Dragados, Cobra, Obras Subterráneas (OSSA), Sacyr Construcción, and Securitas Seguridad España. The decision leaves open the possibility of an appeal to the Social Chamber of the Supreme Court for the unification of legal doctrine.

 

With your registered account

Write your email and we will send you a link to write a new password.