The Supreme Court has issued a ruling that definitively resolves a complex conflict of territorial jurisdiction between courts in Madrid and southern Gran Canaria. The decision, issued by the Civil Chamber under the opinion of Justice Fernando Cerdá Albero, determines that the courts of San Bartolomé de Tirajana must handle a summary judgment claim filed by Escandinava de Electricidad (Fortum Oyjy). The underlying issue in the litigation highlights the procedural difficulties related to determining the actual domicile of debtors and the correct application of mandatory rules of jurisdiction in civil proceedings for the recovery of sums of money.
The case originated on June 29, 2023, when the electricity company filed a monetary claim with the Madrid courts. After the initial assignment to the Court of First Instance No. 103 in the capital and the unsuccessful attempt to serve the defendant, inquiries through the Judicial Neutral Point led to an address located in the municipality of San Bartolomé de Tirajana, Gran Canaria.
With these elements, the Madrid court issued an order of inhibition in favor of the island courts in January 2024. However, far from accepting the case or activating the legal mechanisms of disagreement, the Court of First Instance number 3 of San Bartolomé de Tirajana rejected its jurisdiction in September 2025 and irregularly returned the proceedings to the Madrid dean's office, causing the matter to fall to the Court of First Instance number 35 of the capital and opening a formal conflict that has required the intervention of the high court.
The Civil Chamber reiterates in its legal reasoning that, in summary proceedings for monetary claims, territorial jurisdiction is strictly governed by the mandatory rules established in the Civil Procedure Law, completely ruling out any possibility of express or tacit submission by the litigants. The court emphasizes that the general rule of the perpetuation of jurisdiction prevents a mere failure to serve notice or the subsequent location of secondary addresses from justifying an automatic transfer of case files between judicial districts. To modify the initial jurisdiction, the Chamber's jurisprudence requires rigorous documentary evidence demonstrating that the subsequent address already constituted the actual and effective residence at the precise moment the lawsuit was filed.
A detailed analysis of the official databases provided in the case reveals numerous discrepancies. These include a census address in Madrid updated in March 2025, a police address from February 2024, a traffic record from 2005, and, significantly, a tax domicile in San Bartolomé de Tirajana since November 2011, in addition to Social Security records linked to the San Fernando area.
Faced with this amalgamation of residences, the Supreme Court notes that on the date closest to the filing of the original lawsuit —June 2023— the only address accredited with the intention of permanence and fiscal roots in the terms required by the rule was located in the municipality of Gran Canaria, dismissing the presumption that the subsequent data found on the peninsula invalidated the original jurisdiction.
The ruling by the Civil Chamber annuls the cross-dismissals that have delayed the proceedings for years and firmly establishes that jurisdiction unequivocally lies with the Civil Section of the Court of First Instance of San Bartolomé de Tirajana. The case file has now been sent to the island court for the continuation of the oral proceedings, concluding a procedural cycle that underscores the need for rigorous documentation given the volatility of residences in large tourist areas and areas of inter-territorial mobility.











